Ranking the X-Men Film Scores

As far as superhero films go, it has become sadly accepted that there will be no musical continuity between films—it’s become the exception rather than the rule. It’s understandable that reboots like The Incredible Hulk, The Amazing Spider-Man, Man of Steel, and Christopher Nolan’s Batman would have different scores from the originals (though coincidentally, I didn’t really enjoy the scores from any of these films, especially compared to their predecessors.) Iron Man went from Ramin Djawadi to John Debney to Brian Tyler, with the last two being vastly superior scores to the first, so maybe that wasn’t a bad thing. Nolan’s Batman lost James Newton Howard for the last installment, to its detriment. Thor is going from Patrick Doyle to Brian Tyler and Captain America from Alan Silvestri to Henry Jackman. Perhaps most inexplicable of all, The Amazing Spider-Man is ditching James Horner for Hans Zimmer. And if rumor has it, Tyler may be replacing Silvestri for Avengers: Age of Ultron (or it could be puffery; the original Captain America was rumored to be scored by Michael Giacchino or John Powell at one point). These frustrations are another topic, but the X-Men films were ahead of the curve in that all six were scored by different composers. It has taken seven films for a composer to score two X-Men films with John Ottman slated for X-Men: Days of Future Past. 

With the recent release of The Wolverine, I decided to do a personal ranking of the X-Men film scores. I do not have Marco Beltrami’s score to The Wolverine on CD and only heard it in the film, but there would have to be some pretty epic unused material for me to change its ranking on here.

6. X2: X-Men United (John Ottman)

Ottman’s theme is catchy and rousing, even if the rhythm recalls Henry Mancini’s Lifeforce and the melody is a sped-up variation of Danny Elfman’s Batman. But whenever I listen to the score, I find my mind wandering; most of it sounds like orchestral mush. Things happen and melodic fragments drift here and there, but there’s no discernible structure and the melodies are nebulous and unmemorable. There are apparently themes for Magneto, Jean Grey, Nightcrawler,  Mystique,  and Pyro according to the ever-reliable Wikipedia, but I can’t recall any of them. There’s nothing offensive about the music, but even the main theme doesn’t appear much in the body of the score. The “Suite from X2” contains the best statement of the theme, but only the first 90 seconds and last minute are interesting, with five minutes of noodling in between. One moment I do like is the part is near the end of the film when Xavier, using Cerebro, targets every non-mutant on Earth, and there is an effective, creepy use of pipe organ. But other than that, I don’t really enjoy this score that much.

5. The Wolverine (Marco Beltrami)

Again, I don’t have this score on CD, but I did hear it in the film. I didn’t really pick up on a theme (though from what I’ve read from other reviews, there isn’t really one). It definitely supports the film, but nothing really stood out, apart from sparse use of harmonica in some of the early scenes. Music for the quiet/tender scenes is understated, and the action music is very brutal and somewhat complex—sort of a messier, less structured (and less interesting) version of Elfman’s modern action music. It wasn’t really a theme, but I did like the cue that played during the first part of the end credits (before the extra scene); it really stood out from the rest of the score in a good way. Which was probably why it was in the end credits, but that’s another topic.

4. X-Men Origins: Wolverine (Harry Gregson-Williams)

This isn’t at the absolute top of HGW’s body of scores. Much of the action cues are ostinato based but, as he often does, HGW makes good use of the choir, with some powerful writing in “The Towers Collapse.” “Agent Zero Comes For Logan” is also a pulse-pounding action cue with electric guitars. “Wade Goes To Work” is the most “modern” sounding cue, with percussive electronics and a backbeat, sort of a toned down version of some of the composer’s Metal Gear Solid material. The best part of the score is a great theme for Logan, introduced in “Logan Through Time,” which plays under the title sequence and is perhaps the best track. HGW’s distinctive choral work melds with the theme, which gets two full plays. It appears again at the beginning of “Adamantium” and gets a charged, final playing in “I’ll Find My Own Way” over ascending string ostinatos. The theme does an admirable job portraying Logan’s stoic loneliness and restrained emotion. There’s also a lovely theme for Kayla Silverfox best heard in “Kayla.” HGW has always been good at these tender themes, heard in the quieter moments of scores like Man on Fire, Spy Game, Veronica Guerin, and the first two Narnia films. Unfortunately, the score also contains a fair amount of droning, filler material. Nevertheless, the themes and action are worth listening to.

3. X-Men (Michael K-Men)

I don’t know the full story behind this score, but I do know that director Bryan Singer only chose Kamen because his regular composer (and editor) John Ottman wasn’t available. I also know that Klaus Badelt overlaid a lot of electronic material over Kamen’s score. I won’t use the term “electronic junk” because some of it actually works fine, particularly in the first part of the end credits and “X-Jet”. Because of these factors, the score probably isn’t quite as good as Kamen was capable of, but it is still a worthy effort. Much of it is low-key, but Kamen does have a very good, simple main theme and an unsettling, slithering motif for Mystique. Kamen fans will definitely recognize his delightful style in “Mutant School,” and a heartfelt theme for oboe in “Logan and Rogue” that he also used for Mr. Holland’s Opus. There’s a yeaning adagio in “Concentration Camp” (reused for the opening of First Class) and exciting action music for the climax of the film. The best statement and expansion of the main theme can be heard during the final scene and first few minutes of the end credits (also heard in abbreviated form in “X-Jet.”) The sparse use of the main theme, subtle nature of many of the cues, and electronic overlays may be a turn-off to some, but there are also undeniable highlights that make one wonder what Kamen would have achieved had he done X2.

2. X-Men: First Class (Henry Jackman)

If you watch the documentary on the Blu-ray, you can see a segment on the score where Jackman explains that his original approach was much more orchestral and full-bodied. Furthermore, the theme for Magneto seems simple because it was originally the bass line for a much more elaborate, James Bond-style theme for the character. Stripped-down as the final score is, it is still highly effective, with a great main theme for the X-Men and a simple, badass theme for Magneto with reams of electrifying action music. Shaw’s motif is similar to Magneto’s, heard in cues like “Sub Lift.” More tender music can be found for Mystique in tracks like “Would You Date Me,” and “To Beast Or Not To Beast.” Magneto’s guitar theme highlights brutal cues such as “Not That Sort Of Bank” and “Frankenstein’s Monster.” Guitar backs the main theme in “X-Training” and the introduction to the New Mutants Division and is given a Russian flavor in the aptly named “Mobilize for Russia.” “Rage and Serenity” features the theme at its emotional height as Erik learns how to harness his power and use it to its fullest extent.

Electronics are also deftly incorporated into the numerous thrilling action cues, from the boat fight and “Rise Up To Rule” to the lengthy final battle. Only half of the music for the final battle (or less) is available on CD, but can be heard on the Blu-ray’s isolated score, including fast-paced, adventurous variations on the main theme, the triumphant “Sub Lift,” dramatic renditions of Magneto’s theme for Shaw’s demise, frantic action for Erik’s final attack, and an adagio of sorts for Charles’s and Erik’s parting of ways. “Magneto” and “First Class” present final, full arrangements of the themes for the end credits. Jackman’s score is always interesting and composed with a sense of class (sorry) made even more impressive by the fact that the building blocks of the score are so simple. I would have loved to hear what he would have done had Vaughn directed Days of Future Past.

1. X-Men: The Last Stand (John Powell)

Powell wrote the best X-Men score for the worst X-Men film, an apocalyptic, raging work filled with relentless action and awesome wonder. It has to be said, before I start the raving, that there are some dull, dead spots in the early part of the score, especially before Xavier’s death. But from then on, it’s pretty much an endless action symphony. Powell wrote four primary themes for the film, each different yet able to exist with each other. The main theme builds off of Ottman’s (which in turn was built off of Kamen’s) and the first phrase bears some resemblance in shape to John Barry’s On Her Majesty’s Secret Service, but not too much. There is a jubilant, soaring theme with two distinct phrases that can be attributed to either Angel or the mutant cure. There is a menacing theme for Magneto often played on brass. And finally there is Phoenix’s theme, a vaguely exotic sounding tune that is accompanied by a women’s choir during its most raging statements. Though much of the score is action, there are effective quieter bits, found in “Angel’s Cure,” “X Funeral,” and “Skating and Rogue Leaves.”

But much of the score, especially in its boisterous latter half, showcases, Powell’s penchant for writing complex, rambunctious, almost out-of-control action music. For instance, witness the flutes 30 seconds before the end of “The Death of X” (there’s similar music in “The Phoenix Arises,” but it’s harder to hear because on top of all that orchestral craziness, there’s a chanting female choir as well.) The 20 minutes from “Building Bridges” to “The Phoenix Arises” is a non-stop maelstrom of orchestral frenzy. About 3-4 minutes or so of this is cut from the CD and in truth a bit of fatigue can set in; there is one phrase based on a shortened version of the main theme that plays just a bit too often in the complete score. But once Phoenix/Jean Grey starts disintegrating everybody, the aforementioned female choir enters and Powell has your full attention again. The album version statement of the title theme (almost identical to the end credit version) uses a rhythm from John Williams’s Superman score, while the more interesting film version draws upon Danny Elfman’s Spider-Man, with its swirling strings along with Powell’s own great use of bass strings and brass. One of the few prominent uses of electronics is the final statement of Phoenix’s theme in the end credits. The score can be slow during the first half and exhausting during the second, but it’s undoubtedly a stellar achievement as yet unmatched in the X-Men cinematic universe.

The Future

John Ottman is set to write the score for X-Men: Days of Future Past. As X2 is my least favorite X-Men score, I’m not too wildly keen on it, but Ottman may surprise me. I will say that superhero scores don’t seem to be Ottman’s forte; his scores for X2, Superman Returns, and the two Fantastic Four films were all underwhelming. On the positive side, I did like his score for Astro Boy, and his work for Jack the Giant Slayer, while not great, proves that Ottman has shown some improvement in the fantasy-adventure genre. I know he probably won’t do this, but I would like him to expand on Jackman’s highly effective Magneto theme from First Class because for the life of me I can’t remember what Ottman himself wrote for the character—and I just finished listening to X2! And I suppose a pleasant surprise from Ottman would be better than a disappointment from Powell or Jackman, but for now, my expectations remain tempered.

See also Ranking the X-Men Films